One Hundred Years of Homosexuality: Halperinin which the author supports the social constructionist school of thought associated with the French philosopher Michel Foucault. The work has been praised by several scholars, but criticized by others, some of whom have attributed to Halperin the view that the coining of the word "homosexuality" in the nineteenth century brought homosexuality into existence. The book was often reviewed alongside John J.
Winkler's The Constraints of Desire Halperin addresses the constructivist-essentialist debate on gay history from a constructivist point of view. Halperin believes that the appearance of the English translation of the first volume of Foucault's The History of Sexuality intogether with the publication of the classicist Kenneth Dover 's Greek Homosexuality the same year, marked the beginning of a new era in the study of the history of sexuality.
In Halperin's view, the introduction of the term "homosexual" in the English translation of Richard von Krafft-Ebing 's Psycopathia sexuallis by Charles Gilbert Chaddock marks an important change in the treatment and consideration of homosexuality. According to Halperin, Aristophanes divided men-loving men into two different kinds, youths who loved adult men and adult men who loved youths.
One Hundred Years of Homosexuality was first published in by Routledge. Both reviewed the book alongside John J. Griffin called Halperin's work learned but suggested that he exaggerated ideas drawn from Foucault. Griffin wrote that Halperin did not "succeed in disproving the natural reading of a number of Greek texts, which is that some forms of sexual activity were discountenanced, and that some people were categorized by their sexual activities. In reply, Griffin accused Halperin of inconsistency on the issue.
Nussbaum called Halperin and Winkler "judicious and discriminating classical scholars" with a "mastery of the relevant types of evidence" superior to that of Foucault.
She described their books as "important collections" that were "meticulous and reliable in scholarship, clear in argument. One Hundred Years of Homosexuality was reviewed in the New York Native and received subsequent discussions there, one of which presented the book alongside Winkler's The Constraints of Desire Schneiderman, responding to the playwright Larry Kramer 's criticism of queer theory and the refusal of academics associated with it "to believe that homosexuality has been pretty much the same since the beginning of human One hundred years of homosexuality and other essays on greek love pdf, credited Halperin with offering the strongest objection to a "universal notion" of homosexuality.
Paglia noted that the book had been praised by numerous scholars. However, she strongly disagreed with their assessment of it, and accused Halperin of poor scholarship, careerism, and over-valuing Foucault's ideas. Paglia found the work pretentious and confused, and expressed dismay at Nussbaum's positive review.
She criticized Halperin for implying that homosexuals and homosexuality did not exist until the word "homosexuality" was coined and for basing conclusions about the views of classical Athenians on Aristophanes' speech in Plato's Symposiumnoting that "Aristophanes is a literary characters and not the real-life man on which he was based".
She contrasted Halperin's book unfavorably with John J. Winkler's The Constraints of Desirewhich she described as a "closely associated" work. However, she also criticized Winkler on various grounds. Dinshaw described One Hundred Years of Homosexuality as a "polemical book". The gay writer Neil Miller commended Halperin's book for its lucidity,  while English professor Leonard Barkan called it "brilliant". Dowsett, writing in Practicing Desireobserved that Halperin, like Foucault in The History of Sexuality redraws "the terms of our understanding of ancient male-to-male sexual activity and man-boy love", and that he does so with One hundred years of homosexuality and other essays on greek love pdf "view to the politics of the late twentieth century".
Dowsett saw Halperin's views as following those of both Foucault and the poet and literary critic John Addington Symondsmaintaining that all three present a censored and overly idealized picture of homosexuality and sexual activity in general.
LeVay found Halperin's interpretation of the Symposium strained, noting that while according to Halperin Aristophanes divides men-loving men into youths who love adult men and adult men who love youths, Aristophanes represents the two kinds of love as "different stages on a single life course.
McKnight granted the possibility that Halperin and the other critics may be correct. Murphy wrote that while Halperin claims that erotic preferences are no more fundamental than dietary preferences and should therefore be explained in cultural rather than biological terms, dietary habits themselves can be explained partly in terms of inherent human needs for proteins, fats, and sugars. He criticized Halperin for claiming that the discovery of a gene for homosexuality would refute his ideas about the cultural determination of sexual object-choice, since social constructionism can be interpreted as claiming that sexual orientation is inevitably influenced by social forces and thus does not rule out scientific investigation of the origins of homosexuality.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. Ganymede and the Erotics of Humanism. And Other Essays on Greek Love.
The Use and Abuse of Research into Homosexuality. Homosexuality, Evolution and Adaptation. Out of the Past: Gay and Lesbian History from to the Present. The Ethics of Sexual Orientation Research. Nussbaum, Martha; Estlund, David M. Sex, Preference, and Family: Essays on Law and Nature. Sex, Art, and American Culture: Posner, Richard; Estlund, David M. Sexual Orientation and the Social Constructionist Controversy.
The Mismeasure of Desire: The Myth of Ancient Greek Sexuality. The New York Review of Books. Comparative Studies in Society and History. The Times Literary Supplement New York Native Halperin, David; Griffin, Jasper April 26, Retrieved 17 January Retrieved from " https: Pages to import images to Wikidata CS1 maint: Views Read Edit View history.
Print Hardcover and Paperback. pinehavenabuse.info: One Hundred Years of Homosexuality: And Other Essays on Greek Love (New Ancient World Series) (): David M Halperin: Books. Halperin's subject is the erotics of male culture in ancient Greece. Arguing that the modern concept of "homosexuality" is an inadequate tool for. labored throughout the past hundred years. An early distinguished from other sorts of non-conformity to one's culturally defined sex.